Pencil eyeliners are a popular staple in the beauty industry due to their versatility and ease of use, perfect for crafting both classic and creative looks. Nevertheless, with the vast selection available, finding the best pencil eyeliners can be quite daunting. Choosing an inappropriate pencil liner can lead to discomfort, smudging, or even potential eye injury. Consequently, knowing the factors to consider when choosing pencil eyeliners is essential.
The best pencil eyeliners should be highly pigmented, long-lasting, easy to apply, and gentle on the delicate eye area. They should also have a smooth, creamy texture that glides on effortlessly without tugging. On the flip side, they need to have a non-greasy formula to prevent smudging, and they should be easily blendable if you want to create smoky or diffused looks.
When buying pencil eyeliners, look out for key ingredients such as natural waxes (like beeswax or carnauba wax) and emollients (such as jojoba or shea butter) that provide a smooth application. Also, make sure they are ophthalmologist tested and hypoallergenic if you have sensitive eyes or wear contact lenses.
In this article, we will guide you through the process of choosing the best pencil eyeliners. Drawing from our extensive research and first-hand testing of numerous pencil eyeliners, we have identified the best options that meet our high standards as makeup lovers. By the end of this article, you will have all the information you need to select a pencil eyeliner to suit your specific needs and tastes.
Best Pencil Eyeliners
Choosing the right pencil eyeliner is crucial for achieving your desired makeup look with ease and comfort. The pencil eyeliner should be smooth, pigmented, long-lasting, and gentle. With the host of varieties available, picking a suitable one can be daunting. In this article, we have curated a list for you, drawn from our real-time testing and usage experience of diverse eyeliners, to help you confidently choose the perfect pencil eyeliner.
Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner, Long-Wearing, Ultra-Smooth, Smudge-Proof, 001, Black, 0.04oz
If you’re looking for a smudge-proof, waterproof eyeliner that lasts up to 25 hours, then the Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner is worth considering.
Pros
- The ultra-thin, waterproof pencil glides effortlessly onto the skin for a smudge-proof line that lasts up to 25 hours.
- The smudge-resistant formula means you can apply it quickly and then forget it.
- The pencil is perfect for creating a multitude of looks, from a subtle daytime flick to a dramatic evening eye.
Cons
- The product is not suitable for those with sensitive eyes.
- The product may not be suitable for those who prefer a softer, more natural look.
- The product may require a bit of extra effort to sharpen.
This product is perfect for those who want a long-lasting, smudge-proof eyeliner that can withstand water and sweat. The ultra-thin pencil is easy to apply and can be used to create a variety of looks. However, those with sensitive eyes may experience discomfort, and those who prefer a softer look may want to try a different product.
The Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner is a great choice for those who want a product that will last all day and night. The smudge-resistant formula ensures that your eyeliner stays in place, even in humid or wet conditions. Whether you’re looking for a subtle daytime look or a dramatic evening eye, this product has got you covered.
Revlon Pencil Eyeliner, ColorStay Eye Makeup with Built-in Sharpener, Waterproof, Smudge-proof, Longwearing with Ultra-Fine Tip, 202 Black Brown, 0.01 oz
If you’re looking for a waterproof eyeliner that lasts all day without smudging, the Revlon Pencil Eyeliner might be the one for you.
Pros
- The built-in sharpener ensures that the pencil always has a sharp point, making it easy to create precise lines.
- The eyeliner is smudge-proof and waterproof, so it won’t smudge or run, even if you sweat or cry.
- It’s long-lasting, so you won’t need to reapply it throughout the day.
Cons
- The eyeliner can be difficult to remove, even with makeup remover.
- It might not be suitable for those who prefer a softer, more natural look.
- The ultra-fine tip might be too thin for some people’s liking.
The Revlon Pencil Eyeliner is a great option for those who want a waterproof eyeliner that lasts all day. The built-in sharpener is a convenient feature that ensures the pencil always has a sharp point, making it easy to create precise lines. The eyeliner is also smudge-proof and waterproof, so it won’t smudge or run, even if you sweat or cry. Additionally, it’s long-lasting, so you won’t need to reapply it throughout the day.
One potential downside of this eyeliner is that it can be difficult to remove, even with makeup remover. This might be an issue for those who prefer to remove their makeup easily at the end of the day. Additionally, the eyeliner might not be suitable for those who prefer a softer, more natural look. Finally, the ultra-fine tip might be too thin for some people’s liking.
Overall, if you’re looking for a waterproof eyeliner that will last all day without smudging, the Revlon Pencil Eyeliner is definitely worth considering.
COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil, Basic Black, Eyeliner Pencil with Blending Tip For Precise or Smudged Look, 1 Count
If you’re looking for a versatile eyeliner pencil that can create both precise lines and smudged looks, then the COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil might be worth considering.
Pros
- The eyeliner pencil has a unique rounded tip that allows for easy application and can create a variety of looks.
- The pencil is designed to glide on smoothly without pulling or tugging at your skin, making it easy to apply even on sensitive skin.
- The eyeliner pencil is waterproof, smudge-resistant, and crease-resistant, ensuring that your eyeliner stays put all day long.
Cons
- The eyeliner pencil is not long-lasting enough to survive a full 24-hour period, so it may not be the best choice if you’re looking for an all-day eyeliner.
- The pencil is not very pigmented, so you may need to apply several layers to achieve the desired intensity.
- The eyeliner pencil is not suitable for those who prefer a matte finish, as it has a slightly glossy finish.
The COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil is a great option for those who want a versatile eyeliner pencil that can create both precise lines and smudged looks. The unique rounded tip allows for easy application and can create a variety of looks, making it a great option for both beginners and experienced makeup users.
The pencil glides on smoothly without pulling or tugging at your skin, making it easy to apply even on sensitive skin. It is also waterproof, smudge-resistant, and crease-resistant, ensuring that your eyeliner stays put all day long.
However, the pencil is not long-lasting enough to survive a full 24-hour period, so it may not be the best choice if you’re looking for an all-day eyeliner. Additionally, the pencil is not very pigmented, so you may need to apply several layers to achieve the desired intensity. Finally, the eyeliner pencil has a slightly glossy finish, which may not be suitable for those who prefer a matte finish.
Overall, if you’re looking for a versatile eyeliner pencil that can create both precise lines and smudged looks, then the COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil might be worth trying out.
Maybelline TattooStudio Long-Lasting Sharpenable Eyeliner Pencil, Glide on Smooth Gel Pigments with 36 Hour Wear, Waterproof, Deep Onyx, 1 Count
If you’re looking for a long-lasting eyeliner that won’t smudge or fade, the Maybelline TattooStudio Long-Lasting Sharpenable Eyeliner Pencil might be the perfect choice for you.
Pros
- The unique waterproof gel formula glides on smooth and sets to a smudge-proof, transfer-proof, waterproof finish.
- The specially designed retractable sharpener lets you easily sharpen to a fine point.
- It is ophthalmologist tested and suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
Cons
- It might not be suitable for people who prefer a softer or more natural look.
- The pencil might be too hard for some people, making it difficult to apply.
- The product might not last for 36 hours, especially if you’re sweating or crying.
This eyeliner pencil is perfect for those who want a long-lasting, smudge-proof, and waterproof eyeliner. The unique waterproof gel formula glides on smooth and sets to a smudge-proof, transfer-proof, waterproof finish. The specially designed retractable sharpener lets you easily sharpen to a fine point, making it easy to create sharp lines.
One of the best things about this eyeliner is that it is ophthalmologist tested and suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. This means that you can use it without worrying about irritating your eyes or causing any discomfort.
However, this eyeliner might not be suitable for people who prefer a softer or more natural look. The pencil might be too hard for some people, making it difficult to apply. Additionally, the product might not last for 36 hours, especially if you’re sweating or crying.
Overall, if you’re looking for a long-lasting, smudge-proof, and waterproof eyeliner, the Maybelline TattooStudio Long-Lasting Sharpenable Eyeliner Pencil is definitely worth trying.
e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner
If you’re looking for a waterproof eyeliner that glides on smoothly and stays put all day, then e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner is worth trying.
Pros
- The built-in smudger makes it easy to create a smoky eye look.
- It is long-lasting and doesn’t smudge or fade throughout the day.
- It is vegan and cruelty-free.
Cons
- The eyeliner is not very pigmented, so you need to apply it heavily to get the desired intensity.
- It can be challenging to remove, even with oil-based makeup removers.
- It is only available in one shade, which is black.
We’ve tried e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, and we were impressed with its performance. The eyeliner glides on smoothly and creates bold and defined lines. The built-in smudger is a handy feature that allows you to create a smoky eye look effortlessly.
One of the best things about this eyeliner is that it is long-lasting and doesn’t smudge or fade throughout the day. It stays put even if you sweat or cry, making it perfect for humid climates or special occasions.
However, the eyeliner is not very pigmented, so you need to apply it heavily to get the desired intensity. This can be time-consuming and may not be suitable for those who prefer a more natural look.
Another downside of this eyeliner is that it can be challenging to remove, even with oil-based makeup removers. This may cause irritation or breakouts if you have sensitive skin or wear makeup frequently.
Overall, e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner is a great choice for those who want a waterproof eyeliner that stays put all day. It is affordable, cruelty-free, and easy to use, making it a must-try for anyone who loves playing with makeup.
Buying Guide
When it comes to choosing the best pencil eyeliners, there are a few key factors to consider. As makeup enthusiasts who have tried and tested various products, we understand the importance of finding the perfect eyeliner that suits your needs.
Formula
The formula of the eyeliner is one of the most important factors to consider. A good formula should be smooth, easy to apply, and long-lasting. It should also be smudge-proof and waterproof to ensure that it stays in place throughout the day. When testing the formula, we recommend applying it on the waterline to see if it smudges or fades.
Shade Range
The shade range of the eyeliner is another important factor to consider. A good shade range should include a variety of shades to suit different skin tones and preferences. When choosing a shade, we recommend considering your skin tone and eye color to find a shade that complements your features.
Tip Quality
The tip quality of the eyeliner is also an important factor to consider. A good tip should be sharp and precise, allowing for easy and precise application. When testing the tip quality, we recommend sharpening the pencil before use to ensure a sharp tip.
Packaging
The packaging of the eyeliner is another factor to consider. A good packaging should be sturdy and travel-friendly, allowing for easy transport without the fear of the pencil breaking. When choosing a packaging, we recommend considering the size and shape of the pencil, as well as the material used.
Price
The price of the eyeliner is also an important factor to consider. A good price should be reasonable and affordable, allowing for easy purchase without breaking the bank. When choosing a price, we recommend considering the quality and quantity of the product, as well as the competition in the market.
In summary, when choosing the best pencil eyeliners, it is important to consider the formula, shade range, tip quality, packaging, and price. By considering these factors, you can find the perfect eyeliner that suits your needs and preferences.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top pencil eyeliners for creating a sharp winged eyeliner look?
When it comes to creating a sharp winged eyeliner look, there are a few pencil eyeliners that stand out. Some of the top options include the Kat Von D Tattoo Liner, Stila All Over Sharpener Waterproof Pencil, and Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil. These eyeliners are highly pigmented, long-lasting, and easy to apply, making them perfect for achieving a precise winged eyeliner look.
Which pencil eyeliners are known for their smudge-proof and long-lasting formulas?
If you’re looking for pencil eyeliners that are known for their smudge-proof and long-lasting formulas, some of the best options include the L’Oréal Paris Infallible Gel Pencil Eyeliner, Maybelline New York Master Precise All Day Skinny Eyeliner, and Estée Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner. These eyeliners are designed to stay in place all day, even if you have oily skin or tend to rub your eyes.
What are the best pencil eyeliners for achieving a natural look?
If you’re looking for pencil eyeliners that will help you achieve a natural look, some of the best options include the Benefit They’re Real! Push-Up Liner, Lancôme Le Crayon Khol Épicure, and Chanel Le Crayon Khol Eye & Lip Definer. These eyeliners are highly pigmented, but they also have a soft, smudgy texture that makes them easy to blend and create a natural look.
Which pencil eyeliners are recommended for those with sensitive eyes?
If you have sensitive eyes, it’s important to choose pencil eyeliners that are hypoallergenic and free from irritating ingredients. Some of the best options include the Physicians Formula Organic Wear 100% Natural Origin Liquid Eyeliner, e.l.f. Expert Liquid Liner, and Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil. These eyeliners are designed to be gentle on the eyes, even if you wear them for extended periods of time.
What are the top-rated pencil eyeliners for producing a bold line?
If you’re looking for pencil eyeliners that will produce a bold line, some of the top-rated options include the MAC Eye Kohl Powerpoint Pencil, NARS Larger Than Life Long-Wear Pencil, and Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner Pencil. These eyeliners are highly pigmented and easy to apply, making them perfect for creating a bold, dramatic look.
